Skip to main content

Table 1 Demographic characteristics

From: Prediction of dysphagia aspiration through machine learning-based analysis of patients’ postprandial voices

 

Normal

Aspiration

p-value

Gender (N (%))

 Men

41 (32.03%)

52 (74.29%)

 < 0.001*

2: 30.76, df: 1)

 Women

87 (67.97%)

18 (25.71%)

Age (mean ± SD)

 Total

61.16 ± 13.00

72.30 ± 12.03

 < 0.001**

 Men

63.27 ± 13.57

72.25 ± 11.68

0.001**

 Women

60.16 ± 12.66

72.44 ± 13.34

0.001**

Comorbid conditions (N (%))

 Total

  Central nervous system disorders

17 (13.28%)

18 (25.71%)

 < 0.001***

2: 36.10, df: 5)

  Digestive system and dental disorders

3 (2.34%)

12 (17.14%)

  Pulmonary disorders

4 (3.12%)

9 (12.86%)

  Other cancers

7 (5.47%)

3 (4.29%)

  Aging-related disorders

12 (9.38%)

8 (11.43%)

  None

85 (66.41%)

20 (28.57%)

Men

  Central nervous system disorders

5 (12.20%)

11 (21.15%)

0.002***

2: 18.54, df: 5)

  Digestive system and dental disorders

1 (2.44%)

12 (23.08%)

  Pulmonary disorders

2 (4.88%)

8 (15.38%)

  Other cancers

2 (4.88%)

2 (3.85%)

  Aging-related disorders

5 (12.20%)

6 (11.54%)

  None

26 (63.41%)

13 (25.00%)

Women

  Central nervous system disorders

12 (13.79%)

7 (38.89%)

0.140***

2: 8.31, df: 5)

  Digestive system and dental disorders

2 (2.30%)

0 (0.00%)

  Pulmonary disorders

2 (2.30%)

1 (5.56%)

  Other cancers

5 (5.75%)

1 (5.56%)

  Aging-related disorders

7 (8.05%)

2 (11.11%)

  None

59 (67.82%)

7 (38.89%)

  1. *The Chi-square test results show a significant difference. To address gender bias, separate models were constructed for each gender (male and female). The data was then divided into 10 folds for each gender. After that, the results were combined in the gender-neutral model, effectively removing any gender-related biases
  2. **The Mann–Whitney U test results indicate a significant difference between the two groups. However, to eliminate bias, participants under the age of 40 were excluded from the analysis
  3. ***Regarding the comorbid conditions, a Chi-square test was conducted for analysis. While there are no significant differences observed among females, statistically significant differences are found in the overall dataset or males. However, vocal fold-related conditions were excluded, and dysphagia can occur in conjunction with various other conditions, which may account for differences when compared to the normal group