Skip to main content

Table 1 Quality assessment scoring of 82 included studies

From: Validity and reliability of wearable inertial sensors in healthy adult walking: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Study
Information
Study Ques.Study DesignMeasurementAnalysesRecTotal
AuthorYearRefQ1Q2Q3Q4Q5Q6Q7Q8Q9Q10Q11Q12/24%
Abhayasinghe2019[20]10120N/A002100731.8%*
Al-Amri2018[21]2112222221122083.3%
Allseits2018[22]21120N/A0122021359.1%*
Allseits2017[23]21120N/A1222021568.2%*
Aminian2004[24]10020N/A1221011045.5%*
Atallah2014[25]21220N/A0122101359.1%*
Backhouse2013[26]21120N/A1122011359.1%*
Bautmans2011[27]2202021122221875.0%
Ben Mansour2015[28]20020N/A112001940.9%*
Benoussaad2016[29]21020N/A111001940.9%*
Bertoli2018[30]21021N/A2222021672.7%*
Bolink2016[31]21120N/A2122121672.7%*
Bruijn2010[32]20120N/A1211111254.5%*
Buganè2012[33]21120N/A1120011150.0%*
Byun2016[34]22120N/A1221211672.7%*
Chalmers2014[35]20020N/A101000627.3%*
Chapman2019[36]10020N/A0222011045.5%*
Charlton2019[37]2122222022222187.5%
Cole2014[38]21120N/A1122121568.2%*
Cooper2009[39]21020N/A021000836.4%*
Dalton2013[40]21020N/A1121121359.1%*
Del Din2016[41]21120N/A1221121568.2%*
Esser2009[42]00120N/A101111836.4%*
Furrer2015[43]21120N/A2122111568.2%*
Godfrey2015[44]21120N/A1121121463.6%*
Gonzalez2016[45]21121N/A1120011254.5%*
Gorelick2009[46]2112021221221875.0%
Greene2012[47]21220N/A2221001463.6%*
Greene2010[48]20120N/A2221011359.1%*
Hamacher2014[49]1011021022111250.0%
Hamacher2015[50]2011020022221458.3%
Hartmann2009[51]22120N/A1222121777.3%*
Hartmann2009[52]2212021122121875.0%
Henriksen2004[53]2111020221221666.7%
Huang2016[54]21120N/A1220021359.1%*
Hundza2014[55]20020N/A102002940.9%*
Jarchi2014[56]20120N/A1122121463.6%*
Karatsidis2019[57]21120N/A2021121463.6%*
Kavanagh2006[58]2122022221121979.2%
Kitagawa2016[59]21010N/A001002731.8%*
Kluge2017[60]2112001121111354.2%
Köse2012[61]20110N/A002001731.8%*
Lebel2017[62]21020N/A1121121359.1%*
L’Hermette2008[63]11010N/A101101731.8%*
Liikavainio2007[64]2111022220121666.7%
Liu2009[65]21010N/A0121021045.5%*
Lord2008[66]00120N/A002121940.9%*
Lyytinen2016[67]2102021221121666.7%
Maffiuletti2008[68]21120N/A2121021463.6%*
Manor2018[69]2212020011121458.3%
Mariani2012[70]21120N/A1122021463.6%*
Mariani2013[71]21120N/A1121021359.1%*
McGrath2012[72]20120N/A1221111359.1%*
Moe-Nilssen1998[73]2001021122121458.3%
Nishiguchi2012[74]2100021121111250.0%
Ohtako2001[75]20020N/A011102940.9%*
Orlowski2017[76]2112021122221875.0%
Pepa2017[77]20120N/A0222011254.5%*
Reynard2014[78]2211021022221770.8%
Sabatini2015[79]21120N/A2212021568.2%*
Saremi2006[80]2011022120021354.2%
Schmitz-Hübsch2016[81]21120N/A0122011254.5%*
Sejdic2015[82]20120N/A1220021254.5%*
Selles2005[83]21020N/A1221111359.1%*
Senden2009[84]2011021121111354.2%
Sijobert2015[85]21120N/A1220001150.0%*
Silsupadol2017[86]21120N/A1222121672.7%*
Steins2014[87]10110N/A1022211150.0%*
Storm2016[88]20120N/A1220021254.5%*
Teufl2019[89]2001022121121458.3%
Teufl2018[90]2111022021221666.7%
Trojaniello2014[91]21120N/A1020011045.5%*
Trojaniello2014[92]21120N/A2212021568.2%*
Trojaniello2015[93]21120N/A2220021463.6%*
van der Straaten2018[94]2212021022221875.0%
van Schooten2013[95]2012021022121562.5%
Washabaugh2017[96]1112010122121458.3%
Wundersitz2015[97]21120N/A0222111463.6%*
Xia2017[98]21020N/A2121111359.1%*
Zhang2013[99]11120N/A201010940.9%*
Zijlstra2013[100]2111021121121562.5%
Zijlstra2003[101]21010N/A011001731.8%*
  1. *Percentage calculated out of 22 as studies did not qualify for reliability and were not assessed on Q6 for sample retention