Task | TBI (iLimb) | CBPA (body-powered) - Hosmer hook 5XA | CBPA (body-powered) - TRS adult prehensor | CBPA (body-powered) - Becker hand |
---|---|---|---|---|
Loading car, carrying items for more than 8m distance. | Useful grip for cut out box handles, not useful for recessed grip grooves. Limb positioning effect [90, 91] with sudden dropsa. | No problem. Great balance for posturec. | No problem. Requires focus to keep cable tense (VC paradigm). | No problem. Great balance for posture. |
Taking notes holding notepad in the field | Feasible but not ideal. Clumsy grip types with unforeseeable force vectorsb. | No problem.c | No problem but requiring focus to keep cable tense (VC paradigm)b. | No problem. |
Undressing body | Grip by far too weakb. | Good support, finding right angle for best grip requires attentionb. | Perfect support, top application domain for VC control paradigm.c | Perfect support due to shape and built-in grip lock. |
Grip by far too weak. Suspension started to come offb. | Good support, but grip forces sometimes not large enoughb. | Perfect support, top application domain for VC control paradigm.c | Good support, but grip forces sometimes not large enoughb. | |
Grip too weak. Limb positioning effect [90, 91] with sudden dropsa. Unforeseeable grip force vectors [93]b. | Good support, but grip forces sometimes not large enough. | Perfect support, top application domain for the VC control paradigmc. | Good support, but grip forces sometimes not large enough. | |
Cleaning, disinfecting terminal device. | Costly thin cosmetic glove not to be replaced by user; no work rubber glove to be worn according to manufacturer [89]. | Metal split hooks easy to swap or disinfect. Wearing thick rubber glove over hook device not technically difficult and not prohibited by manufacturer. | Wearing rubber glove fingers to TRS prehensor allows for easy disinfection; not prohibited by manufacturer specifications. | Becker hand fits humanly used rubber protection gloves, that can be worn as they both fit well and are not prohibited by manufacturer specifications. |
Typing | COG too far in front, device too heavy. Device shape and weight cause shoulder pain. Suspension results in severe friction problems on stump skin after long typingab. | Perfect.c | Good, but Hosmer 5XA has the better angleb. | COG too far in front, and Hosmer 5XA has the better angleb. |
Meetings, presentations | Grip problems as the hand does not handle large pens with difficult to tear of caps well. Loud source of distraction [96, 97]b. | Handles paperwork and pens well. | Handles paperwork and pens well. | Perfect, least amount of distraction with grip suited well to typical tasksc. |
Soft covers for terminal device | Gloves very thin to avoid impeding hand mechanism. Perforating damage [87], as soon as 10 min into light work. Approved gloves costly, only sold by manufacturer. | Silicone tubing affordable, easy to mount, enhance form closure. Under full work load, replace after 1–2 weeks. | Sheet rubber, double sided tape and work glove nitrile fingers are placed on the claws to enhance form closure. Under full work load, replace after 1–2 weeks. | Fits humanly worn normal work gloves such as nitrile work gloves to enhance form closure and grip. Under full work load, replace after 1–2 weeks. |